We are honored to share that our work for Paul Rudolph’s Sarasota High School Addition was one of fifteen recipients of the 2021 Modernism in America Awards. Thanks also to the successful efforts of Sarasota Architectural Foundation, Carl Abbott, FAIA, Sarasota County School Board, Tandem Construction, and Harvard Jolly, the modern icon will continue to be a part of our community for decades to come.
About the Awards
These projects highlight the best in preservation practice by today’s architects, designers, preservation professionals, and grassroots advocates. This year’s awards recognize model preservation efforts that elevate original design intent while adapting to current day needs, inventory and survey projects that synthesize large swaths of information into digestible content, and critical advocacy initiatives that put public input and education at the forefront
The 2021 winners include:
AWARD OF EXCELLENCE
Netsch House (Chicago, IL)
Pālehua Cabin and Guest Cottage (Kapolei, HI)
Chicago Federal Chicago Federal Plaza United States Post Office (Chicago, IL)
Rothko Chapel (Houston, TX)
Boston City Hall Conservation Management Plan (Boston, MA)
Modern in the Middle: Chicago Houses 1929-75 (Chicago, IL)
Sarasota High School (Sarasota, FL)
CITATION OF MERIT
Greene Residence (Los Angeles, CA)
NYPL Macomb’s Bridge Library at Harlem River Houses (New York, NY)
Detective Building (Pittsburgh, PA)
Architecture of James H. Johnson (NY)
Tropical Modernism at University of Hawai‘i at Mānoa (Honolulu, HI)
Boston Government Service Center (Boston, MA)
Milwaukee Preservation Alliance
SPECIAL CITATION FOR GRASSROOTS INITIATIVES
Mafundi Building (Los Angeles, CA)
Now in its eighth year, the Modernism in America Awards, under the guidance of its distinguished jury members led by jury chair Marcel Quimby, FAIA, uplifts projects that represent the best of modern preservation and advocacy work. As in past years, the jury continues to value holistic approaches in all categories. In the Design category, projects were applauded for accomplishing highly successful restorations while maintaining a light touch and respect for the original design intent, at times with relatively small budgets. The restoration of the Pālehua Cabin and Guest Cottage in Hawaii was one such modest yet impressive project recognized for preserving Vladimir Ossipoff’s family treat and landscape and opening it to the public. The long-awaited restoration of the Rothko Chapel was recognized for developing a comprehensive strategy that prioritizes accessibility and visitor interaction with the art by developing a new skylight system and site resiliency due to climate change. The Chicago Federal Plaza United States Post Office was also an exemplar in getting the important details just right, taking to heart Mies’ own “less is more” philosophy and restoring this publicly accessible United States Post Office building for the foreseeable future.
Winners in the Inventory/Survey category stood out for the ability to aggregate massive quantities of disparate information and present it to the public in an enjoyable and user-friendly format. The Boston City Hall Conservation Management Plan was particularly notable for achieving this while also working with multiple levels of city government.
The Awards also recognize both successful and ongoing preservation advocacy efforts. The Advocacy Awards serve as a reminder that although there is not always a positive outcome, the hard work of individuals and organizations can have beautiful results. This is especially clear in the case of Paul Rudolph’s Sarasota High School, which was a successful multi-year advocacy campaign that resulted in a successful restoration effort. Docomomo US is highlighting the work of the Milwaukee Preservation Alliance as a model for combining both advocacy and public education in modern preservation efforts and acknowledging the public process to redevelop the Boston Government Services Center by the State of Massachusetts.
Speaking on the projects recognized and the impact of the Awards program, Docomomo US President Theodore Prudon noted, “Docomomo US continues to acknowledge the depth and diversity of projects developed in the United States during the mid-twentieth century. This year’s preservation efforts highlight the exceptional amount of care, research and time that owners, architects and teams put into unique projects with challenging designs.” Docomomo US Executive Director Liz Waytkus added, “once again, advocacy efforts over time continue to have a positive and meaningful impact on preservation projects. There is no greater change than in Boston where two of the most misunderstood and complex projects, City Hall and the Government Center, are now being celebrated and re-envisioned with plans in hand.”
The Modernism in America Awards is the only national program that celebrates the people and projects working to preserve, restore and rehabilitate our modern heritage sensitively and productively. The program seeks to advance those preservation efforts; to increase appreciation for the period and to raise awareness of the ongoing threats to modern architecture and design.
The 2021 Modernism in America Awards will be presented in-person on Thursday November 11, 2021, at the Design Within Reach Third Avenue Showroom in New York City (proof of Covid-19 vaccination and negative Covid test will be required). Tickets and event sponsorship opportunities are available at www.docomomo-us.org/modernism-in-america-awards.
Advocacy Award of Excellence
Sarasota High School
Location: Sarasota, FL
Original Architect: Paul Rudolph
Advocates: Sarasota Architectural Foundation; Carl Abbott, FAIA; Jonathan Parks, AIA
Restoration Team: SOLSTICE Planning and Architecture (Jonathan Parks, AIA and Selma Göker-Wilson, RIBA); Harvard Jolly Architecture; Tandem Construction
The Advocacy Award of Excellence is given for the preservation and restoration of Sarasota High School (SHS). Signs that Paul Rudolph’s 1960 addition to the original Neo-Gothic high school might be threatened first appeared in 2007, when the Sarasota County School Board decided to demolish Rudolph’s nearby Riverview High School and also announced they would “appropriately rehabilitate” Sarasota High School. In 2012, advocates successfully listed SHS on the National Register of Historic Places. Shortly thereafter, the School Board announced plans to significantly alter Rudolph’s design, prompting Sarasota Architectural Foundation (SAF) to launch an advocacy campaign. Their efforts included an organized lecture with leading experts such as Carl Abbott, FAIA, Joe King, and the Docomomo US/Florida chapter; hosting a 2-day community design charrette; the publication of a 32-page report with recommendations, hosting the first Docomomo US National Symposium in 2013, the establishment of the Paul Rudolph Scholarship Fund in addition to social media and letter-writing campaigns. Due to this pressure, the School Board collaborated with SAF, Jonathan Parks, AIA of Solstice Planning and Architecture, and Harvard Jolly Architecture to establish renovation guidelines. The renovation was completed in 2015, transforming it into the “front door” of the high school campus. The distinctive concrete canopy walkway, an important element of Rudolph’s design linking his addition with the original high school (now the Sarasota Art Museum), was also saved twice over. In 2015 and 2017, SAF convinced both the Art Museum and the High School respectively to retain significant sections of the walkway. SAF provided funds to help cover the costs for the High School’s portion of the walkway.
Advocacy Committee chair Todd Grover praised the project for “hitting all of the right points - technical elements such as concrete repair, as well as advocacy.”
Advocacy Committee member Barbara Campagna emphasized that it is a “beautiful project that shows the results of the time and energy put into it.”
Photo credit:
Sarasota High School
Caption: Sarasota High School during Sarasota MOD weekend event with cheerleaders.
Credit: Veronika Bajtala